[#8920] [Christos] Feedback about Survival

Please log in

State: more information
Closed
Date:
2017-11-17 15:15
Priority: more information
5
Submitted By:
Sarthak Pati (sarthakcbica)
Assigned To: more information
Saima Rathore (saimarathore)
Component: 
Applications: Survival Prediction Index
Version: 
None
Severity: 
None
Resolution: 
Awaiting Response
Operating System: 
All
Summary: more information
[Christos] Feedback about Survival

Detailed description

  • testing Survival module: specified model directory doesn't exist. The model doesn't seem to be there in the distribution or sample data. NOT WORKING
  • More on Survival module: Using existing model, specifying the folder. Specifying test data. Running—crashes the entire s/w.

Response

Message

Date: 2017-12-14 19:28
Sender: Sarthak Pati

New training works fine.


Date: 2017-12-14 19:08
Sender: Sarthak Pati

Testing on Existing Model:
  • No longer crashes (Beta.g)
  • What is the significance of SPI? Basic information would be nice
  • The information that was used to generate the result needs to be restructured: first should be model directory, then the input directory and finally the output directory (the way the pop-up dialog is structured); also, this information should be saved in the output directory (especially considering that we are asking a user for an output directory and not a single file)
  • In the output directory, there is a single file 'results.csv', which has 2 columns: subjectID and Result; but there are 4 fields getting populated from the next line onwards, for example, the first line is: AAAA,2.952639,-0.808882,0.191118. This is confusing and needs to be clarified with different headers
  • It is mentioned that the SPI is saved in results.csv; but there is nothing there referencing this. If someone runs Survival and generates results, they will not be able to correlate the SPI information (and how is it calculated for X number of subjects)

Attached Files:

Name Download
No Files Currently Attached

Changes:

Field Old Value Date By
status_idOpen2018-04-16 18:10sarthakcbica
New Message2017-12-14 19:28sarthakcbica
MessageTesting on Existing Model:
  • No longer crashes (Beta.g)
  • What is the significance of SPI? Basic information would be nice
  • The information that was used to generate the result needs to be restructured: first should be model directory, then the input directory and finally the output directory (the way the pop-up dialog is structured)
  • In the output directory, there is a single file 'results.csv', which has 2 columns: subjectID and Result; but there are 4 fields getting populated from the next line onwards, for example, the first line is: AAAA,2.952639,-0.808882,0.191118. This is confusing and needs to be clarified with different headers
  • It is mentioned that the SPI is saved in results.csv; but there is nothing there referencing this. If someone runs Survival and generates results, they will not be able to correlate the SPI information (and how is it calculated for X number of subjects)
2017-12-14 19:15sarthakcbica
New Message2017-12-14 19:08sarthakcbica