[#10448] Inconsistent qform and sform offsets with 3d crop

Please log in

State: more information
Open
Date:
2024-11-07 18:28
Priority: more information
3
Submitted By:
Christopher Kovach (ckovach)
Assigned To: more information
Nobody (None)
Hardware: 
All
Product: 
None
Operating System: 
All
Component: 
None
Version: 
v1.0
Severity: 
minor
Resolution: 
None
Summary: more information
Inconsistent qform and sform offsets with 3d crop

Detailed description

We encountered a confusing problem with image coregistration which we ultimately traced to a discrepancy of the qform and sform offsets in nifti files generated with the 3D crop option (-x). Evidently the srow_z value in the header is updated with cropping, but the qoffset_z is not. Some versions of ITK default to the qform transformation when both are present, and we ended up with images aligned in voxel space but not in scanner space. I suggest either updating qoffset_z to match srow_z(4) or setting the qcode value to NIFTI_XFORM_UNKNOWN (0) to indicate that the qform transform no longer matches scanner space.  


Response

No Responses Have Been Posted

Attached Files:

Name Download
No Files Currently Attached

Changes:

No Changes Have Been Made to This Item