open-discussion > PESTICA stage 3 (Cardiac & Respiratory freq)
Showing 1-6 of 6 posts
Apr 15, 2013 02:04 PM | Pouya Ghaemmaghami
PESTICA stage 3 (Cardiac & Respiratory freq)
Dear Eric and All,
In stage 3, we need to select the proper frequency manually (I know that in batch mode its done automatically) you mentioned in the tutorial that If we don't have confidence, we can zoom larger. Actually i have no idea about these frequencies. is there anyway that we can compare our noise frequency (both cardiac and respiration) with some maps (in terms of QA). because i have no idea how these frequency should look like!
i know you said, you've never seen outside the 48-85 and 10-24 breaths or beats per min range. but i need some qa maps to be sure that my pestica estimation of these cardiac and respiration freq are fine! till now whenever i ran pestica i just hit pressed enter key!! because i had no idea!
In stage 3, we need to select the proper frequency manually (I know that in batch mode its done automatically) you mentioned in the tutorial that If we don't have confidence, we can zoom larger. Actually i have no idea about these frequencies. is there anyway that we can compare our noise frequency (both cardiac and respiration) with some maps (in terms of QA). because i have no idea how these frequency should look like!
i know you said, you've never seen outside the 48-85 and 10-24 breaths or beats per min range. but i need some qa maps to be sure that my pestica estimation of these cardiac and respiration freq are fine! till now whenever i ran pestica i just hit pressed enter key!! because i had no idea!
Apr 15, 2013 02:04 PM | Erik Beall
RE: PESTICA stage 3 (Cardiac & Respiratory freq)
Hi Pouya,
I think just accepting the defaults is fine, we (Jian Lin, Mark Lowe and I) are working on a study comparing 1) manually selecting vs 2) batch mode, and in a handful of studies it doesn't seem to matter, although we haven't completed this study yet. I will post the results here, but it will likely be mid-May when we complete our analysis.
Erik
I think just accepting the defaults is fine, we (Jian Lin, Mark Lowe and I) are working on a study comparing 1) manually selecting vs 2) batch mode, and in a handful of studies it doesn't seem to matter, although we haven't completed this study yet. I will post the results here, but it will likely be mid-May when we complete our analysis.
Erik
Apr 15, 2013 02:04 PM | Pouya Ghaemmaghami
RE: PESTICA stage 3 (Cardiac & Respiratory freq)
Thanks a lot :)
Feb 2, 2015 07:02 PM | Eduardo A Garza Villarreal
RE: PESTICA stage 3 (Cardiac & Respiratory freq)
Hi all
On this same topic:
Can Stage 3 be automated?
In my data I rarely had to zoom in and for all 80 fMRIs the whole processing using a bash script took about a week because I had to be going back to see if Stage 3 was on, for each session and subject.
Can this step be automated so I don't have to choose the windows by hand?
Thanks in advance
Eduardo Garza
On this same topic:
Can Stage 3 be automated?
In my data I rarely had to zoom in and for all 80 fMRIs the whole processing using a bash script took about a week because I had to be going back to see if Stage 3 was on, for each session and subject.
Can this step be automated so I don't have to choose the windows by hand?
Thanks in advance
Eduardo Garza
Feb 2, 2015 08:02 PM | Erik Beall
RE: PESTICA stage 3 (Cardiac & Respiratory freq)
Hi Eduardo,
Sorry, that is indeed frustrating. This stage can be automated by using the "-b" flag for batch mode. Let me know if it works for you or if it keeps halting asking for your input.
Erik
Sorry, that is indeed frustrating. This stage can be automated by using the "-b" flag for batch mode. Let me know if it works for you or if it keeps halting asking for your input.
Erik
Feb 4, 2015 04:02 PM | Eduardo A Garza Villarreal
RE: PESTICA stage 3 (Cardiac & Respiratory freq)
Hi Erick
Thanks for the quick reply. More frustrating would be to not have PESTICA, but I'm glad there is a way to batch it.
Eduardo
Thanks for the quick reply. More frustrating would be to not have PESTICA, but I'm glad there is a way to batch it.
Eduardo